Haakaa vs electric pump: Which is best in 2022?

Haakaa vs electric pump

Haakaa is a silicone suction breast pump that is meant to simulate the experience of natural breastfeeding. This pump is particularly popular for infant-feeding mothers looking for a cost-effective solution.

The Haakaa breast pump is popular for its efficiency, low cost, and ease of use. It’s also been suggested as a viable solution for mothers who wish to continue breastfeeding after a job or work.

Electric pumps are a more advanced form of a manual pump. If you do need something more powerful or have difficulties with your hands, it can be used in place of the Haakaa and other manual pumps.

What is Haakaa?

The Haakaa breast pump is made of silicone. It’s composed of medical-grade silicone that’s free of BPA, PVC, and phthalates. It may be sanitized by boiling for 2-3 minutes in water or in the top rack of your dishwasher, making it safe and sanitary. The suckers are extremely silent, and they require no wires, batteries, or assembly because they operate only on suction power.

Between feeds, the Haakaa silicone breast pump is designed to fit perfectly into any nursing bra and express directly from the breast you’re not feeding on on the opposite side. You can use it as often or as little as you like, it all depends upon your choice!

What is an Electric Breast Pump?

The electric Breast Pump is essentially a device that aids in the expression of breast milk. It’s made to assist you in milk collectors by mimicking a baby’s natural suction habit or feeding habit.

The majority of electric breast pumps are battery-operated and portable, and some may even be used in your car. It operates by sucking milk into a collection bottle with a suction cup placed over the breast. After that, the amount of milk in the bottle may be calculated.

Electric pumps are used to reduce bloating, collect milk for later use, or boost milk production. They can also assist babies who are unable to hold on to the breast and feed themselves.

Is Haakaa breast pumps More Effective Than an Electric Pump?

If you’re a breastfeeding mother, this is likely one of the most important problems you have. The short answer to this is: No! The long answer, on the other side, seems to be more complicated to understand.

The Haakaa breast pump is a device that helps mothers breastfeed their children without having to use a noisy, inconvenient, and costly electric pump. It’s also considerably less expensive and time-consuming than an electric one.

An electronic nursing pump, on the other hand, is a fully automated method of breastfeeding children. Electric pumps are often more powerful than Haakaa pumps. However, they are more expensive, and you must charge them to use them on the move.

It all boils down to personal preference. What is the most effective method for you? It all depends on how comfortable and practical you want to be.

When is it OK to utilize a Haakaa?

As a general guideline, if you’re breastfeeding and have access to a Haakaa, you should always use one. However, there are a few occasions in which a Haakaa can be particularly useful:

·   If you’re trying to collect breastmilk for your infant while they’re gone.

·   If you want to enhance the amount of milk produced by one breast while your baby is nursing on the other.

·   If your baby refuses to be fed, you can collect the milk using the Haakaa and save it for later use.

·   If you wish to collect the milk while it is leaking, you must do so while it is still leaking.

·   If you wish to relieve the pain in your cracked nipples.

When is it OK to utilize an Electric Pump?

Similar to Haakaa, there are times when using the electric pump is the best option. When you don’t want to use a manual pump Haakaa, it works best because it requires less effort. Furthermore, an electric pump can come in helpful when you wish to collect milk quietly.

·   When you want to collect more milk without any effort.

·   You can know the amount of milk that you have collected in the storage.

·   You can collect the milk from both sides at the same time without pumping.

·   It lets you feel the baby’s suction pattern while collecting the milk.

The Differences: Haakaa Vs. Electric Pump

If you want to decide which option, you should choose between a Haakaa and an Electric Pump. Here are the factors you should consider while making the crucial decision.


Haakaa pump milk has a vacuum-like suction that is powerful enough to take milk from the breast while being gentle. It’s compact, light, and easy to transport. It requires no assembly or cleaning and is ready to use in seconds.

An electric motor provides suction to pull milk from the breast by squeezing the nipple using an electric pump. They’re a little bigger than Haakaa pump and need to be put together before usage. They also have a lot of moving parts that must be cleaned after each use.

Because Haakaa pump has stronger suction than an electric pump, expressing milk from your breasts will be easier. The Haakaa can also be used to express breast milk, which is crucial for breastfeeding a premature baby. Moreover, Haakaa pump increase supply as well which is good for low milk supply moms as well. But there is no straight answer to” how much milk” or “how much extra milk”. All I can say is it varies.


The Haakaa pump is tiny and lightweight, making it easy to transport in a handbag or diaper bag. It’s also simple to clean, so you won’t have to be concerned about it becoming dusty in between usage.

If you need something which can automatically collect the breast milk supply without any effort but is larger and not easy to carry, the electric pump can be a better option.


Because electric pumps use a lot of pricey electric components, it’s only natural that they’ll be more expensive. So, if you’re on a tight budget and need a reliable nursing solution, a Haakaa breast pump is a good option. Though, if you don’t have a price limitation, an electric pump is a superior option.


Because a Haakaa is a manual breast pump, it does not require any electricity to function. Furthermore, you won’t have to worry about charging it while traveling with your baby.

The Electric Pump, on the other hand, will require power to operate, and if you don’t have access to one, you may be in trouble. Depending upon your usage, you can pick any of the breastfeeding solutions.

Is Haakaa a Viable Alternative to an Electric Pump?

Can you replace an electric pump is a common question moms face very frequently. As a mother, I’ve used both the Haakaa and the Electric breast pumps, and I’m happy to share my experiences with both. As far as I’ve used both products, I’ve discovered that Haakaa and Electric pumps are very distinct from one another and that they can be useful at different times.

Haakaa is simple to use for me, whether I’m at home or out. While my son is nursing on the opposite side, I frequently utilize Haakaa. Furthermore, Haakaa is far more convenient for me than an Electric Pumps and as far I witnessed Haakaa increase milk supply as well.

I found the electric pump to be a little difficult to operate in one breast and other breast(opposite breast). I don’t use it very often because it requires charging(power outlet), and I don’t feel any better when I use the electric pumps also it has a slight learning curve. Therefore I prefer the Haakaa replace pump for expressed milk or milk saver in freezer stash for baby nurses.

How to Choose the Best Haakaa Pump?

The first pumping hands free need is that it is simple to use without let down to any struggle to create breastmilk. You want something that fits comfortably in your hand has a secure grip and doesn’t make you feel as if you’ll drop it every time you use it.This is the big advantage.

You don’t want your body to spend forever trying to pull breastmilk supply out of your breasts. Therefore it has to be quick! Finally, it should include some sort of indicator or meter so you can see when your breasts are full from your body in a closed system and ready to pump or when they’re empty, so you don’t over-pump or keep on pumping and pumping.

How to Choose the Best Electric Breast Pumps?

Electric breast pumps come in three varieties: single, double pump, and manual if you need to express milk supply while away from home or while your infant is napping, single pumps are great.

When pumping in the morning or evening before bedtime, double pumps allow you to express both breasts at the same time and save time.

Physical breast pumps are small and compact, but they need more work than other types of electric pumps since they utilize manual squeezing motions to extract milk from your breasts rather than a motorized device.

Final Verdict

As a result, everything comes down to the personal preference of a mom. Personally, I as a mom prefer the Haakaa pump(manual breast pump) to replace an electric pumps since it is more comfortable and quieter without the motor noise, and having a lid for the pump is more sanitary, but that is just my opinion.

But, in the end, you must come to your own judgments(like few ounces or low supply or simply suction), because selecting which is the finest will mostly depend on your personal preferences. Just don’t take your opinion to a hospital grade breast pumps. I as a moms have replace an electric pump in the first few months(early days) only to feed my baby via nursing session breast milk when I lack extra time. The milk saver haakaa replace is enough for you untill you are up for milk donation.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.